清朝瓷器仿品走进国际拍卖会 又是“国宝帮”惹的祸？

---

---

6 L1 G& P1 S9 r& j

年关将至，国内外的艺术品秋拍已经落的七七八八了，国际标杆“苏、佳”拍卖（苏富比、佳士得）也已收官，小编虽然没有去现场参拍，但还是全程关注了。就瓷杂类来说，整体感觉不温不火，几件重器最后的成交价也没让人眼前一亮。

% q* n; I# i( l# l

虽如此说，明代官窑、清三代细路及官窑早已不是普通的工薪阶级能消受的起的。眼光虽挑，难奈“囊中羞涩”，那怎么办呢？机智如小编就早早关注了清中晚期的官窑产品。理由是：

1、清中晚官窑价格低，市场潜力大。

( ^, g4 E/ {; Q' ]

2、官窑产品比起老普的东西总体会精致讲究，可玩性高。

3、完整器有一定存世量，可以做系列收藏。

% L6 y! F, J2 Q9 \' P) i$ Z, t  E

但也正因如此，造假工厂也深知其理，故晚清官窑的仿品也接踵而来，且精且多。在线下交易或是拍卖上频繁出现，往往又“药性”十足，迷惑力强，眼力、经验欠缺些的朋友容易中招。

今天我们请华夏收藏版主奚风老师来给我们举例讲讲这类器物的新老问题怎么看。

! v. L% A* W* J9 A- H0 M; P7 }

纵观近年晚清官窑瓷器仿品，从大运瓷到定烧瓷，从慎德堂到大雅斋，几无遗漏。像粉彩八吉祥、五彩龙凤碗、开光节令碗、红地喜字碗、色地暗刻龙等，更是重灾区所在，且分辨难度较大。

1 g# t3 h. J4 ?) L$ x! L

列举一件“大清道光年制款黄料轧道开光粉彩山水碗”仿品来说，如下图

& s3 o, w9 J. \* n: p1 Z. E& {7 \

这件器物黄料轧道四开光，开光内分别绘制四组粉彩山水纹，轧道地上间饰四组洋彩花卉，大清道光年制六字款，书写规矩，胎白足圆，口沿有一小瑕疵，初看真是一件不错的官窑藏品。

有的藏友可能不禁会说，画的真漂亮。

且慢，其实像这样的制品，已经不算官窑仿品的上乘之作了。只是因为假的见得太多，真的见得太少，有些藏友恐怕已经“价值观移位”了。

东西真不真，主要靠比较。我们看一件关善明旧藏的同类制品，这件瓷器发表在1983年出版的《晚清官窑瓷器》上，名家旧藏，又出版时间早，应该是比较靠谱的标准器了，如下图。

清道光 黄料扎道开光

大清道光年制

如果将两件器物进行比较，问题立马就显露出来了。由于图片问题，我们今天主要看彩绘上的差别。有以下三个方面：

一、是轧道，相对来说，仿品轧道凤尾草纹过于刻意、凌乱，这同时也跟黄料彩的质地有关系。

. t2 }0 K! Y- m) P8 U" m

二、是洋彩花卉，不论是画工、还是彩料，差距还是蛮明显的。

8 E  ?/ C! |8 q" D

三、是开光内的粉彩山水，仿品用笔过于荒疏，整体韵味差较多，部分彩料也存在明显的问题。

% V. O2 e+ [/ T& f. U' h

当然，一对一的比较，有时候可能不太容易说明问题。

& V6 L! h( ^( R0 A6 j1 i

这一对是2011年嘉德秋拍的器物，放大看是不是和上文的仿品相似度更高呢。这件器物素白瓷胎映衬出宝相花明快妍丽的色彩，愈显光华天成。外壁以黄彩轧道为地，剔勾细腻。开光处绘山水人物图，山水楼台错落有致，人物描绘生动传神，深具国画风骨，可比照仿品细细对照区分。

现在随着真品资源的越来越稀缺和仿品的不断升级，真品与仿品间的差异确实已经越来越小，鉴别的困难越来越大。这里面的危险性，不是自己拿着银子去试试，恐怕是很难体味的。不过仿品终究是仿品，如果谁有心将大量晚清官窑瓷器分别作彩料、画工、款识等方面的排列比对，真伪之间的红线，就会慢慢清晰起来。

一个粉彩碗光彩绘上的道道尚如此多，如果你对自己手中的藏品缺乏自信或是在“淘宝”时想要降低“吃药”的风险，那就拍照上传至华夏收藏网鉴定估价板块，寻求版主老师们的鉴定吧。

4 t9 O+ @/ h; m/ v% ?# w  o

（文章源自网络   版权属原作者）

---

转载请保留当前帖子的链接：https://www.beimeilife.com/thread-38018-1-1.html 谢谢

都说国外收藏家都在传：中国的瓷器不管是哪个拍卖行的，别买就对了;p, 防不胜防！！

看这个刚刚结束的， 中国瓷器把中国国家博物馆的馆藏都搬来了


http://www.lunds.com/Auctions/AntiqueAndArt/2676/Imaged/

LOT 240 Chinese Ming Dynasty Scholar's Table. Estimate: $4,000 - $6,000	LOT 242 18th Century Chinese Huang Huali altar coffer. Estimate: $2,000 - $3,000	LOT 244 17th/18th Century Chinese 100 Treasures cabinet on original stand. Estimate: $1,500 - $2,000
LOT 277 19th Century Chinese large round carved display table inset with marble. Estimate: $750 - $1,250	LOT 201 19th Century Chinese carved short display table with marble inset. Estimate: $500 - $700	LOT 73 George III style Mahogany - framed Sofa Estimate: $400 - $600
LOT 265 19th Century Chinese display table inset with marble. Estimate: $400 - $600	LOT 75 19th C. Mahogany architect's table with leather insert. Estimate: $200 - $400	LOT 261 19th Century ornately carved bench. Estimate: $300 - $350
LOT 274 Late Victorian settee with pink upholstery. Estimate: $150 - $300	LOT 258 Victorian Mahogany Rent Table Estimate: $200 - $300	LOT 255 19th C. Mahogany secretaire Estimate: $200 - $300
LOT 222 18th Century Chinese rectangular side table. Estimate: $150 - $200	LOT 307 Mahogany Drop-Leaf Table of George II style. Estimate: $125 - $175	LOT 202 Edwardian set of four upholstered chairs. Estimate: $50 - $100
LOT 61 Mahogany Stool with saddle seat and "H" stretcher. Estimate: $50 - $75	LOT 68 Georgian Style Side Chair. Estimate: $50 - $75	LOT 85 George III Hepplewhite Style Side Chair with shield back. Estimate: $50 - $75

[size=0.9em]Items of interest (15 Lots)

LOT 311 Louis XV-XVI ormolu mounted Chinese porcelain (Kangxi) and lacquered encrier Estimate: $5,000 - $10,000	LOT 306 Excellent 18th. cen. French Louis XV bronze and ormolu desk encrier in Grecian style Estimate: $500 - $1,000	LOT 287 Pr.of Limoges pate-sur-pate plaques- Young Women playing lyre & tambourine Estimate: $400 - $600
LOT 196 Pair of spelter figures mounted on wooden bases-par Bruchon Estimate: $250 - $500	LOT 276 Russian pre-revolution c.1900 hand hammered brass vessel with handles & Imperial warrant Estimate: $200 - $400	LOT 278 Limoges pate-sur-pate plaque- Young Woman and Boy Fishing Estimate: $150 - $300
LOT 250B Pair of early bronze barley twist candle sticks Estimate: $150 - $300	LOT 65 Early carved wooden figure group- "Christ Leading a Child" Estimate: $150 - $300	LOT 63 Early carved wooden angel standing on a ball Estimate: $150 - $300
LOT 247 Oak three bottle tantalus. Estimate: $175 - $225	LOT 123 Early carved wooden standing religious figure Estimate: $75 - $150	LOT 64 Early carved polychrome religious figure Estimate: $100 - $150
LOT 170 Two Limoges pate-sur-pate shallow dishes Estimate: $75 - $125	LOT 224 19th. cen. W.B.Cobridge salt glazed pitcher commemorating marriage of Edward & Alexandra 1863. Estimate: $75 - $100	LOT 279 Pair of small classical style metal figured busts Estimate: $50 - $75

[size=0.9em]Asian Items (38 Lots)

LOT 212 Fine Qing jade elephant and boy Estimate: $1,250 - $1,750	LOT 238 Chinese Ming/Qing cloisonne vessel with gilt bronze kilins Estimate: $1,250 - $1,750	LOT 239 A good 19th Century Qing peaches vase Estimate: $1,250 - $1,750
LOT 8 Kangxi (1662-1722) blanc de chine European hunters subject Estimate: $750 - $1,000	LOT 233 Chinese Qing Claire de lune bottle vase Estimate: $500 - $750	LOT 281 Good pair of 19th C. Qing hat stands decorated with boys playing Estimate: $400 - $600
LOT 235 Large Qing jade incense vessel with palace dog finial. Estimate: $400 - $600	LOT 215 Ming or earlier recumbent jade water buffalo Estimate: $300 - $400	LOT 213 Ming/Qing jade marriage bowl with rams heads Estimate: $250 - $350
LOT 214 Ming/Qing recumbent lion Estimate: $150 - $300	LOT 243 Pair of Ming straight back chairs. Estimate: $200 - $300	LOT 122 Qing heavily potted blue and white bowl with transitional mark (1620- 1683) Estimate: $150 - $300
LOT 192 Qing blue and white bottle vase Estimate: $150 - $300	LOT 167 Chinese finely carved stone Guanyin with dog Estimate: $100 - $200	LOT 227 Chinese signed painting Estimate: $125 - $175
LOT 210 Chinese Kangxi marked round wooden box with inscription Estimate: $125 - $175	LOT 166 Chinese Tang figure of a lady Estimate: $100 - $150	LOT 237 Chinese cafe au lait vase with peaches and boys Estimate: $100 - $150
LOT 200 Qing large ginger jar Estimate: $75 - $150	LOT 174 Good Qing burgundy oil splash cabinet vase Estimate: $100 - $150	LOT 6 Qing scholar's water pot Estimate: $100 - $150
LOT 264 Small Modern Japanese Gold Lacquered Tray Estimate: $75 - $125	LOT 229 Pair of 19th century Qing plates with birds Estimate: $75 - $125	LOT 208 Chinese bronze incense burner. Estimate: $75 - $125
LOT 176 Chinese Qing export tray and cups with intertwined handles. Estimate: $75 - $125	LOT 223 Good Chinese Qing export plate with figures Estimate: $75 - $125	LOT 160 Chinese Qing barber bowl. Estimate: $75 - $125
LOT 2 Chinese Qing celadon brush washer. Estimate: $75 - $100	LOT 175 18th C. Qing dark brown cabinet vase Estimate: $50 - $100	LOT 79 Small 19th Century Qing charger with dragons and flowers Estimate: $50 - $75
LOT 152 Finely carved Qing miniature teapot. Estimate: $50 - $75	LOT 154 Chinese cinnabar box Estimate: $25 - $50	LOT 69 Chinese heavily potted celadon bowl Estimate: $25 - $50
LOT 12 Qing blue and white porcelain rectangular pillow. Estimate: $25 - $50	LOT 162 Chinese lemon yellow bowl. Estimate: $25 - $50	LOT 158 Chinese Republic period celadon bowl with foliage. Estimate: $20 - $40
LOT 216 Pair of Chinese snuff bottles. Estimate: $15 - $30	LOT 4 Chinese Anhua bowl. Estimate: $15 - $30

[size=0.9em]Uncategorized (19 Lots)

LOT 299 19th C. mahogany bureau with serpentine front drawers. Estimate: $750 - $1,250	LOT 231 19th C. carved walnut sideboard. Estimate: $500 - $1,000	LOT 308 Set of six Georgian carved mahogany side chairs with pierced backs. Estimate: $250 - $500
LOT 181 Oriental carved and pierced hardwood bed surround. Estimate: $300 - $500	LOT 134 Gilt marble based candelabrum. Estimate: $400 - $450	LOT 270 19th C. mahogany corner whatnot. Estimate: $200 - $300
LOT 248 19th C. mahogany chest of drawers. Estimate: $150 - $300	LOT 193 19th C. inlaid mahogany sideboard. Estimate: $200 - $300	LOT 249 Pair of Edwardian armchairs. Estimate: $200 - $300
LOT 22 Large carved oak wardrobe with mirrored door. Estimate: $150 - $300	LOT 198 Victorian bronze griffon motif candlesticks. Estimate: $200 - $250	LOT 151 Mahogany mirrored back curio cabinet. Estimate: $150 - $200
LOT 67 19th century inlaid mahogany knee-hole desk. Estimate: $150 - $200	LOT 219 19th C. kidney shaped desk. Estimate: $125 - $175	LOT 60 18th century coffer. Estimate: $125 - $175
LOT 92 Victorian mahogany dining table. Estimate: $75 - $125	LOT 195 Upholstered settee. Estimate: $50 - $75	LOT 82 Victorian love seat with two cushions. Estimate: $50 - $75
LOT 301 Austrian china decorative plate with tambourine player motif. Estimate: $40 - $60

[size=0.9em]Carpets & Rugs (6 Lots)

LOT 143 Good quality Tabriz rug Estimate: $1,500 - $1,750	LOT 144 Good quality Tabriz rug Estimate: $1,500 - $1,750	LOT 310 Tabriz semi-antique rug Estimate: $500 - $1,000
LOT 259 Persian semi-antique rug Estimate: $400 - $600	LOT 204 Persian semi-antique rug Estimate: $400 - $600	LOT 59 Asian rug approx. 5"6" x 8'4". Estimate: $250 - $500

[size=0.9em]Figurines (3 Lots)

LOT 296 19th. century Meissen bust of a French Royal child(Bourbon) Estimate: $1,000 - $2,000

LOT 295 19th. century Meissen bust of French Royal child(Bourbon) Estimate: $1,000 - $2,000

LOT 280 Pair of Capo-di-monte small china busts Estimate: $75 - $150

[size=0.9em]Oriental (5 Lots)

LOT 283 Chinese carved jade covered urn on a wooden stand Estimate: $1,000 - $1,500	LOT 253 Chinese 19th. century letter box with gilt painted decoration and cloisonne inset panel. Estimate: $150 - $300	LOT 171 Pair of cloisonne vases with dragon decoration Estimate: $125 - $175
LOT 173 Pr.of Oriental egg shell porcelain bowls on wooden stands-one with cover. Estimate: $50 - $75	LOT 183 Oriental china figured pillow/box Estimate: $25 - $50

[size=0.9em]Carriage Clocks (2 Lots)

LOT 288 French brass repeating carriage clock with date and month function in a fitted box. Estimate: $750 - $1,250

LOT 156 Brass carriage clock Estimate: $100 - $150

[size=0.9em]Prints (3 Lots)

LOT 34 Etching att. to Francisco Goya Estimate: $250 - $500

LOT 39 Two framed Picasso prints marked verso "Galerie Maeght Estimate: $300 - $500

LOT 99 Two Coloured Engravings of "Scottish Lords" Estimate: $100 - $150

[size=0.9em]Paintings & Prints (5 Lots)

LOT 108 19th. century oil on canvas signed E.Topham Estimate: $400 - $600	LOT 275 Oil on canvas signed G.Van Rooy Estimate: $75 - $125	LOT 250 Oil on canvas indistinctly signed- possibly Guy Johnson Estimate: $75 - $125
LOT 125 Early oil on board in a carved and pierced period frame Estimate: $50 - $100	LOT 228 Unsigned pastel Estimate: $50 - $75

[size=0.9em]Canadian Art (5 Lots)

LOT 294 Watercolour signed Nancy Day Estimate: $100 - $150	LOT 226 Oil on board signed G.D. Markovich Estimate: $100 - $150	LOT 31 Watercolour signed Drost (Louise) Estimate: $75 - $125
LOT 147 Pair of pastels signed D.(Dorothy) Oxborough Estimate: $75 - $125	LOT 38 Oil on board signed Frank Bass '57 Estimate: $50 - $75

[size=0.9em]Maps (1 Lot)

LOT 178 18th. century double page map by Alexis-Hubert Jaillot d.1696-"Le Royaume de France..". Estimate: $400 - $600

[size=0.9em]Books & Manuscripts (3 Lots)

LOT 142 A Summary of Geography and History by Alexander Adam incl. maps-London 1816(Fifth edition). Estimate: $150 - $300

LOT 129 Three vols. "Master Humphrey's Clock" by Charles Dickens(illus.) London 1840. Estimate: $75 - $150

LOT 45 An Essay on Man by Alexander Pope: W.Strahan & T.Cadell London 1777 Estimate: $50 - $75

[size=0.9em]Snuff & other boxes (2 Lots)

LOT 256 19th. century rosewood cased four bottle decanter set. Estimate: $150 - $300

LOT 257 Early 19th. century mahogany desk top brass with brass mounts and key. Estimate: $100 - $150

[size=0.9em]European Art (3 Lots)

LOT 272 Watercolour highlighted with gouache signed HM Estimate: $125 - $175

LOT 289 Unsigned oil on board Estimate: $125 - $175

LOT 55 Watercolour signed H.(Harold) Youngman Estimate: $50 - $75

[size=0.9em]Silver (1 Lot)

LOT 284 Scandanavian silver and enamel salts and spoons circa 1890. Estimate: $200 - $400

[size=0.9em]Porcelain (2 Lots)

LOT 291 Hand painted plates with Venetian scenes signed R.E. Evans. Estimate: $200 - $250

LOT 203 Large Ironstone covered two handled tureen and lid Estimate: $100 - $150

[size=0.9em]Lalique (1 Lot)

LOT 218 Lalique France six piece crystal posie centre piece set. Estimate: $150 - $300